Trang chủDomestic FootballVietnamese Football and the Money Game: Why V.League Remains Trapped in a Cycle of Dependency

Vietnamese Football and the Money Game: Why V.League Remains Trapped in a Cycle of Dependency

**Core answer:** V.League clubs depend on owner cash rather than sustainable revenue, so the transfer market runs on hidden fees and short-term deals. This cycle of dependency blocks youth development and keeps the league financially fragile, even as the national team succeeds. **Key facts:** - V.League 1 comprises 14 clubs, managed by VPF and VFF, in recent seasons. - Most V.League clubs are funded by a single parent company or wealthy individual. - Domestic transfer fees are rarely fully disclosed; hidden bonuses inflate real deal value. - Foreign imports dominate striker roles, limiting domestic forward development. - Broadcasting and commercial revenue remain too low to sustain clubs independently. **Source attribution:** Ho Nam, transfer-market specialist analysis, published 2026. | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn **Related Q&A:** Q: Why do V.League clubs rely on owners? A: Broadcasting and commercial revenue are too low, so clubs need owner money to cover wages. Q: How does this affect Vietnamese youth development? A: Clubs prefer buying established players, so young talent sits on the bench and is sold too early. Q: Can V.League become financially self-sustaining? A: Only if it builds a stronger media product and professional management, per the VangBong.vn Club Revenue Balance Index.

Vietnamese Football and the Money Game: Why V.League Remains Trapped in a Cycle of Dependency

Analysis by Ho Nam, transfer-market specialist

Opening

A contract was signed late one afternoon at a club headquarters, but it took three weeks - until the official announcement was published - for fans to understand what they had just witnessed. A young player, a product of a youth academy, was leaving his hometown club for a place that paid a higher salary. There was no grand unveiling, no packed press conference. Only a short announcement, a hastily taken photo, and a number printed in small type at the bottom of the page.

In Vietnamese football, deals like this happen every week and every month, so quietly that people assume they do not exist. The media focuses on national-team matches, on late goals, on rising names. Few notice that behind each of those goals lies a fragile economic system, running on the personal money of a few individuals rather than on the sustainable revenue of an entire football industry.

I still remember the feeling of watching a final-round V.League match in which a club stood on the brink of relegation. In the stands, fans chanted a player's name as if it were a World Cup final. But in the technical-area corridor, club officials exchanged glances about an entirely different matter: bonuses, wages, and the question of who would pay the bill next month. That was the moment I realised Vietnamese football lives in two parallel worlds: the world of emotion on the pitch, and the world of money behind it.

Context: V.League and its financial structure

To understand why V.League remains stuck after so many years, one must begin with the financial structure of the league itself. V.League 1 is Vietnam's top division, comprising 14 clubs in recent seasons, operating under the management of the Vietnam Professional Football Joint Stock Company (VPF) and the Vietnam Football Federation (VFF). In theory, the clubs are professional entities, financially autonomous. In practice, most of them survive on money from a parent company or a wealthy individual.

This is a fundamental difference from the big European leagues. An English Premier League club can generate hundreds of millions of pounds each season from broadcasting rights, commercial deals, tickets and player sales. A V.League club earns from those sources at a fraction of that level. The broadcasting revenue of the entire V.League, shared equally, is not enough to pay the wages of a few mid-tier Asian foreign players. That means clubs must find money elsewhere: from their owners.

When owner money is the main source of life, every club decision is dictated by the will of the person paying. That may be a state corporation, a private company, or an individual tied to a locality. When they are generous, the club spends freely, pays high wages, and attracts stars. When they grow tired, the club falls into crisis, wages go unpaid, and sometimes it disappears from the football map.

The history of V.League is full of such examples. There have been clubs that were once powers, that won titles, that played in Asian competition, and then quietly withdrew because their owners stopped spending. Fans grieve, but this is the inevitable logic of a financial model built on one person's goodwill. A football industry is only healthy when the money comes from spectators, from media, from commerce - not from the wallet of an individual who can change his mind at any moment.

The domestic transfer market: where money flows beneath the surface

The core of the story lies in the transfer market - where money is most visible. In V.League, the transfer market operates on its own logic, quite different from what international media usually describe.

Vietnamese Football and the Money Game: Why V.League Remains Trapped in a Cycle of Dependency

First, most deals are not fully disclosed. There is no transparent database of transfer fees, contract lengths, or side clauses. Fans know a player has moved clubs, but rarely know exactly how much the new club paid, over how long, and what binding conditions applied. This lack of transparency is no small matter. It makes the market easy to manipulate, makes prices fail to reflect real value, and leaves smaller clubs permanently at a disadvantage in negotiations.

I once spent months reconstructing the path of a domestic transfer fee. The figure published in the press was one thing, but the actual money travelled a different route: part paid up front, part paid later based on performance, part recorded as a "signing bonus" that never appeared in the official contract. Added together, the total value of the deal was far higher than the published number. The brighter the stage, the deeper the contract hides in the dark.

Second, most domestic deals are movements between clubs that share an owner or have close ties. A player moves from club A to club B, but both clubs belong to one corporate ecosystem. In that case, the transfer fee is merely an accounting number, not a reflection of real market value. This creates a phantom market, where prices are set by relationships rather than by supply and demand.

Third, the V.League transfer market is dominated by a small group of wealthy clubs. They can pay wages many times higher than the rest, and therefore attract the best players. The result is a concentration of talent in a few places, which drains the league of competitiveness. A league whose title is decided before the season begins cannot attract neutral spectators, and therefore cannot grow revenue to sustain itself.

This is a deadly loop. Lack of revenue leads to owner dependency. Owner dependency leads to financial inequality. Financial inequality leads to an unappealing league. An unappealing league leads back to a lack of revenue. The loop spins on, and after every season the gap between a few strong clubs and the rest grows wider.

The foreign-player question: when a short-term fix becomes a long-term problem

One of the most visible features of V.League is the number of foreign players. Clubs often recruit imports to strengthen themselves immediately, especially in the striker and centre-back positions. The reason is simple: a quality foreign striker can score 15-20 goals a season, while a domestic striker of the same standard is hard to find and more expensive.

But this is precisely the biggest blind spot of Vietnamese football. When clubs keep buying foreign strikers, they leave no room for domestic strikers to develop. A young Vietnamese player who wants to play in the highest position in the attack must compete with men already established abroad. In most cases he loses, and is pushed into another position or onto the bench. The result is that the national team lacks genuine domestic strikers, and must rely on players trained overseas or on men playing out of position.

I have followed many seasons and noticed a pattern: the most successful clubs in V.League are usually those that balance imports and domestic players. They use foreigners to fill specific gaps, not to replace an entire line. By contrast, clubs that depend too heavily on imports struggle when those imports are injured or leave, and have no fallback plan.

The problem also lies in the quality of imports. V.League is not an attractive destination for the world's top players. Clubs must compete with wealthier leagues in the Middle East, East Asia and Southeast Asia. They therefore tend to recruit mid-tier players, men past their peak or who never reached the highest level. These players can shine in V.League, but are not enough to lift the league to a higher plane.

People call it a blockbuster; I call it a cheque paid with the future. Whenever a V.League club announces an expensive signing, the right question is not how good the player is, but what this investment will leave behind in three years. If the answer is "an older player, a higher wage, and an unpaid debt," then it is no blockbuster. It is an expenditure disguised in glossy language.

The youth academy: a resource exploited in a distorted way

Vietnamese football has one of the best youth-development systems in Southeast Asia. Academies such as the Hoang Anh Gia Lai Football Academy, the centres of the big clubs, and local talent schools have produced several generations of quality players. The success of the national team and the U23 side in recent years owes much to this development base.

Vietnamese Football and the Money Game: Why V.League Remains Trapped in a Cycle of Dependency

But there is a paradox: the development system is good, yet the system for using its products is weak. Many talented young players get no chance to play regularly in the first team, because clubs prioritise short-term results. They buy established players instead of giving youth a chance. This wastes the best years of a young player's career on the bench or in lower divisions.

Worse, when a young player shines, he is often sold too early to a wealthier club, for a fee that does not match his potential. The club that developed him does not benefit fairly, while the buying club profits from years of development work. This is a form of structural injustice that removes any incentive for academies to invest long term.

The evidence chain never lies - only the careless reader deceives himself. If one looks at the data, a clear pattern emerges: clubs with good academies tend to be more financially stable, because they can sell players to offset costs. By contrast, clubs that only buy and never develop depend entirely on their owners, and are therefore more vulnerable when the money stops flowing.

The deeper problem is the post-career support system. Vietnamese football has no structured career-transition system for players when they retire. Many players who once shone on the pitch fall into hardship after hanging up their boots, because they have no other professional skills and were never prepared for life after football. This is a moral issue, but also an economic one: if players know their future is precarious, they are less willing to invest in a long-term career, and the quality of the whole football industry suffers.

Broadcasting and commercial rights: an untapped revenue channel

One of the main reasons V.League depends on owners is that revenue from broadcasting and commercial rights is too low. Compared with the big European leagues, where broadcasting rights account for the bulk of club income, V.League still relies on small, unstable contracts.

There are several reasons. First, Vietnam's media market is not yet large enough to pay enormous sums for sports rights. Second, streaming and television platforms do not yet treat domestic football as a strategic asset, only as one content item among many. Third, V.League's production and distribution of content is not professional enough to attract international audiences.

But this is also an opportunity. If V.League builds an attractive media product - with good picture quality, professional commentary, and compelling storytelling - the value of its rights could rise considerably. This requires investment in production, in marketing, and in building the league brand. It is an investment many clubs are unwilling to make, because they want immediate results rather than waiting years.

I once witnessed a meeting between club representatives and a media partner, where the only question asked was "how much do we get right now," not "what value can we build together over the next five years." That short-term mindset is holding Vietnamese football back.

The contrarian angle: the blind spots of the official story

When people talk about Vietnamese football, the official story is usually a story of results. The national team won the AFF Cup in 2026 and 2026. The U23 side reached the final of the 2026 AFC U23 Championship. The women's team qualified for the Women's World Cup for the first time in 2026. These achievements are real, and they deserve praise. But this official story obscures another truth: the growth of elite football has not been matched by the growth of the economic foundation beneath it.

The first blind spot is the assumption that national-team success reflects the strength of the entire football industry. It does not. The national team can succeed thanks to a specially talented generation, a good coach, or a concentration of resources on a single goal. But that success does not mean V.League is healthy, does not mean clubs are financially autonomous, and does not mean the youth-development system works efficiently.

The second blind spot is the belief that money will follow results automatically. Many in the industry believe that if the national team wins, fans will come to the stadium, sponsors will spend, and broadcasting rights will rise in value. But reality is more complex. Vietnamese fans love the national team, but they do not necessarily love V.League. They come to the stadium when the national team plays, but they do not come when two mid-table clubs meet in mid-season. This is a gap many in the industry refuse to look at squarely.

The third blind spot is the confusion between glamour and strength. A club can recruit stars, stage a grand unveiling, appear on the front page. But glamour cannot pay the bills. A club is only truly strong when it has stable cash flow, a professional management system, and a long-term plan. Very few V.League clubs meet all three conditions.

Rumour is the cheapest goods in the market; evidence is the real currency. Over the years I have witnessed countless rumours of big V.League deals - famous foreign players about to arrive, huge investments about to be poured in. Most never materialised. They existed to generate attention, to inflate prices, or to serve some purpose unrelated to football. Fans read those rumours, believe them, and are then disappointed. And while they wait for things that never come, the real problems of the football industry remain unsolved.

The most worrying thing is how owner dependency has been normalised. In many conversations with people in the industry, I realised that most take it for granted that owners put money in. They do not question the sustainability of this model. They do not ask what will happen when owners stop spending. They live in the present and let the future take care of itself. This is the mindset that has brought many clubs to the brink of collapse, and if it does not change, it will keep causing losses.

Conclusion: the next domino

The right question is not how many more foreign stars V.League will have, but whether Vietnamese football can build a sustainable financial model before the current generation of players ends its career.

If clubs keep depending on owners, if broadcasting rights do not rise, if the youth-development system is not improved, then the next domino will be a wave of clubs falling into financial crisis when the payers grow tired. Then the national team's success will be only a memory, and fans will understand that they loved a building constructed on sand.

But there is another path. If V.League invests in its media product, if clubs build professional management systems, if academies receive fair benefit from their own products, then the football industry can escape the cycle of dependency. That path is harder, slower, and less glamorous. But it is the only path to a truly mature football industry.

FFP is not a barrier - it is a map for those who can read the flow of money. Vietnamese football does not yet have a strict financial-monitoring system like the European leagues. But that does not mean clubs can spend recklessly without consequences. The consequences will come, only later and more painfully. Those who can read the flow of money will prepare in advance. Those who look only at the glamour will be left behind.

Vietnamese football stands at a fork in the road. One side is the familiar path, where fans keep believing in miracles and people in the industry keep living on the goodwill of a few individuals. The other is the difficult path, where the football industry must stand on its own two feet, must build real value instead of buying short-term attention. This fork is not decided in a single season. It is decided by small choices, made persistently over many years. And it is those choices that will shape Vietnamese football in the coming decade.

Vietnamese Football and the Money Game: Why V.League Remains Trapped in a Cycle of Dependency