Trang chủEsportsThe Last of Us Tops the 100 Greatest Games List: The Argument Is About the Yardstick, Not the Game

The Last of Us Tops the 100 Greatest Games List: The Argument Is About the Yardstick, Not the Game

Hồ Cường2026-10-23 11:19Tiếng Việt

2 a.m., Seoul. My eleven-person group chat — four former commentators, two...

2 a.m., Seoul. My eleven-person group chat — four former commentators, two people who once ran tournaments, and a kid born in 2026 who is addicted to ranked ladders — lit up at the same moment with a screenshot: a list of the 100 greatest games ever, published by Kinda Funny Games, with The Last of Us at number one.

The first message came from the 2026 kid: “These people have never played a single ranked match.” The second came from the tournament operator: “You have never read their criteria either. They did not publish any.”

I sat still for about forty seconds. The thing worth discussing sits in that second message. A ranking that withholds its yardstick will always generate argument, and that argument cannot end, because nobody can prove the other side wrong. Ten years in this trade taught me one thing about that structure: when the organiser hides the rulebook, every decision gets read as bias, including the correct ones.

What the public was told is compact. Kinda Funny Games published a list of 100 games; The Last of Us — the 2026 Naughty Dog title — took first place. The backlash was immediate, and the article about it was built in exactly that order: controversy first, the list second, both camps quoted at the end. That ordering inverts cause and effect to maximise tension, and I record it as a craft technique.

Three camps became visible. The first calls the original a safe masterpiece — polished past the point of criticism, but unwilling to gamble. The second ranks the sequel above it: deeper gameplay, larger ambition, in exchange for a narrative structure many readers treat as a flaw. The third, the Sekiro camp, calls both of those choices a victory for cinephiles over systems players.

Then someone asked the plain question: does this list judge gameplay quality, popularity, or historical influence? No official answer exists. The historical line was drawn in a single sentence — from Pong to Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 — which is an industry history seen through a Western AAA lens, with a very recent release placed at the endpoint.

I went back through everything published to find a measurement that could hold up first place. No sales figures. No completion rate. No concurrent player counts. No survey, no weighting table, no methodology. The only quantitative element in the entire piece is rank 1 out of 100 — a placement, and a placement is the output of a scoring process nobody described.

A ranking that withholds its yardstick will be used by two groups applying two different yardsticks at the same time, and both groups are correct inside their own frame. The attacking camp measures systems: mechanical depth, tactical freedom, control quality. The defending camp measures historical influence: the Uncharted → The Last of Us lineage, the way cinematic storytelling became the AAA standard, the moments players still remember a decade later. Those two yardsticks cannot be reconciled by argument. They can only be reconciled by a weighting table, and that table does not exist.

In esports I meet this exact structure every season. When a team wins through vision control and macro tempo, the audience counts kills and calls the match boring. When a team wins through spectacular teamfights, the same audience counts trophies and calls it class. Both sides are ranking with yardsticks they have never written down, and because nothing is written down, nobody can lose.

The “safe versus ambitious” pairing the original article uses to compare the first game with the second is the most durable analytical asset in the whole piece, because it belongs to no single title. In esports that pairing surfaces every time a champion wins with a standard meta composition and then tries to switch to an unfamiliar structure the following season. The first game is the standard composition. The second game is the season of structural change. Fans always pay the first in trophies and the second in praise — two different currencies, and nobody sets an exchange rate.

March 2026. I was 30, working at a sports radio station in Seoul, and I proposed something the newsroom called insane: in the FC Seoul – Suwon Bluewings derby, drop the number 10 Park Chu-young into a false nine instead of using Dejan Damjanović — twelve goals the previous season — as the striker. FC Seoul lost 1-2. Colleagues laughed. I opened the data: the team produced 17 shots, against their own season average of 9.5. The idea was not wrong. The finishing was.

The lesson I took was not about tactics. An opinion without a yardstick cannot be refuted, and it cannot be defended either. I survived that derby because I had 17 shots to put on the table. The people defending The Last of Us at number one have nothing but memory — and memory, however beautiful, has never been data.

Seoul that year did not riot; it simply showed that tactics are written after the match is over. Game canon works the same way. The list is written after the game is over, and the person writing the list is rewriting the history of that game.

Three years later, in the pandemic season, global competitions stopped and stadiums emptied. I built a simulation model from FIFA 20 data and 450 K League matches, then proposed a 30-minute first half, with a projected 23% reduction in muscle injuries. The Korean referees' board rejected it. ESPN Asia republished it. My thirty minutes in the pandemic season taught me this: football does not need more time, it needs fewer illusions. People can reject a proposal; they cannot reject a model they have not read.

That is why I read the Kinda Funny Games list differently from the crowd. The economics of this content format live in the comment section, and the comment section only boils when the criteria are vague. A list that publishes clear weights produces two reactions: agreement, or grounded objection. A list that hides its weights produces thousands of reactions that cannot be adjudicated, and every one of them is an engagement unit. For a publisher, the second option is cheaper, safer, and far more profitable.

The original article contains one telling detail: even dissenters are quoted conceding that the first game is one of the most outstanding in history. That is a consensus-manufacturing device — concede a weaker claim to turn a split into something close to agreement. It dampens backlash, and at the same time it locks first place into a spot nobody bothers contesting anymore.

There is a deeper layer few discuss. A canon list is never purely entertainment content; it is a statement about which design model counts as the industry's benchmark. When first place goes to a linear, cinematic, narrative-heavy action-adventure from a first-party studio, the signal to other studios' meeting rooms is clear: investment in presentation and storytelling will be repaid in critical prestige. That signal appears in no financial report, yet it flows into production budgets over three to five years. In esports I have seen the reverse current: when competitions stopped, people did not sit down to write laments, they went to dissect contracts, release clauses and payroll. Attention always moves toward whatever has structure.

Germany did not die from a lack of talent; it died from trusting its own scheme more than the feet on the pitch. Publishers have their own scheme: lists, rankings, studio lineages, one sentence about Pong and Clair Obscur. Players have hands. When the scheme and the hands diverge, the scheme always wins in the article, and always loses in memory.

The appendix of the original piece is where I stopped longest. Same outlet, same page: LCK, VCT Pacific 2027, VCT Champions 2026, GAM Esports, LOUD, MLBB Vietnam, K/DA, a sponsor-named VISA VMC Fall 2026 event. These are leads, not evidence: no source figures, no measurement window, no baseline. But the existence of that headline block says one thing — a Western general-gaming outlet now treats esports as a standing vertical, large enough to publish daily.

Now the part where I might be wrong, and I will build the strongest version of the other side before attacking it.

The strongest case against me: games cannot be measured the way football can. There is no expected-value metric for emotion, no heat map for grief. A

Cầu thủ liên quan